Ruling politicians in New Delhi continue to hype their country's economic growth even as the Indian currency hits new lows against the US dollar, corporate profits fall, electrical power demand slows, domestic savings and investment rates decline and foreign capital flees Indian markets. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has questioned India's GDP and independent economists Professors Arun Kumar and Ashoka Modi and investment banker Ruchir Sharma have detailed why the Indian official data can not be trusted. It seems that the BJP-led government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi is fast losing credibility by politicizing the civilian bureaucracy and the military brass to project their economic and military failures as successes.
![]() |
| IMF Gives C Grade to India's GDP Data |
Beyond the disputed claim of being the "fourth largest economy", the Modi government's failure on the national health and wellness front is also getting more attention. “Air is unbreathable. Water is undrinkable. Food is adulterated. What’s the point of becoming the 4th largest economy?” asked India-American technology entrepreneur Sabeer Bhatia in an X message recently. Gita Gopnath, Harvard professor of economics, said at the World Economic Forum in Davos this week that the economic impact of pollution on India is more severe than the effects of tariffs imposed on the country. “About 1.7 million lives are lost every year in India because of pollution. That’s 18% of the total deaths in India,” Gopinath said, quoting a World Bank study. “Even from an international investor’s perspective … the pollution holds you back.”
![]() |
| Unsafe Drinking Water in India Claimed as 4th Largest Economy. Source: DownToEarth |
An international badminton tournament in India has brought global spotlight on the lack of basic hygiene in India. Foreign players complained about dusty floors, dirty courts, bird droppings and unhygienic conditions at the India Open in New Delhi. “I think the floors are dirty. There is a lot of dirt on the courts. There’s bird excrement. There are birds flying around in the arena,” said 28 year-old Denmark women’s singles player Mia Blichfeldt. Andres Antonson, world number three badminton player, withdrew from the India Open Super 750 in New Delhi for the third consecutive year, choosing to pay a $5,000 fine. He cited "extreme" hazardous air pollution in Delhi as the reason for skipping the mandatory tournament, arguing it is not a safe place to hold the event.
The IMF has recently expressed doubts about Prime Minister Narendra Modi's BJP government's GDP data. It has particularly questioned the government's statistical methodologies, inflation measurement, and the estimates of the informal economy used in reporting the country's gross domestic product. Professor Arun Kumar of Jawaharlal Nehru University believes the IMF's concerns are valid. He thinks the real size of India's economy is only half of what is officially claimed. “The economy is almost 50% wrong – when the government says it’s $3.8 trillion, my estimate is it is probably still $2.5 trillion because we are overestimating the unorganized sector, which is actually declining. This is building up over a period of time,” Kumar told Indian journalist Karan Thapar.
In its recent assessment, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has given a "C" grade to India's national accounts. In particular, the IMF has raised the issue of the government using 2011-12 as the base year as being outdated, the discrepancy between production and consumption data and the use of Wholesale Price Index, and not a Producer Price Index, to deflate many economic activities to derive real GDP from nominal GDP.
![]() |
| Indian Firms Falling Corporate Profits. Source: Bloomberg |
Corporate profits of Indian firms are growing at a much slower pace than the 8.2% GDP growth in its most recent quarter. Net income for Nifty 50 Index firms likely rose 1.1% in the three months through Dec. 31 from a year earlier, according to analyst estimates compiled by Bloomberg. That would be the slowest pace in five quarters, weighed down by deteriorating margins for banks. Falling profits and declining currency are causing foreign capital to flee Indian markets. Foreign Portfolio Investors (FPIs) pulled out over $20 billion from Indian equities in 2025, marking a severe, sustained withdrawal that has continued into 2026. Net Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has seen consecutive monthly outflows, including $1.67 billion in October and $446 million in November 2025. Investment banker Ruchir Sharma wrote about it in a Financial Times op ed titled "India needs to import more capital and export fewer workers". Ruchir wrote: "Most strikingly, corporate revenue normally grows (or shrinks) with the economy — in any country. But last year corporate revenue growth for listed companies in India decelerated to barely half the GDP growth rate"
![]() |
| Falling Indian Rupee. Source: Reuters |
The source of the biggest error is the way India estimates the informal economy which, including agriculture, accounts for almost 45% of GDP. To do so, India uses the formal sector as a proxy to estimate the performance of the informal sector. But if the two sectors are moving in opposite directions, as has happened after demonetization, GST imposition and the pandemic, you could end up overestimating the unorganized sector.
Indian-American economist Ashoka Mody, author of "India is Broken", has argued that the current unemployment crisis in India is a direct result of the destruction of the informal sector, particularly the mom and pop stores that employed a large number of Indians.
Questions about the veracity of India's official GDP figures are not new. These have been raised by many top economists. For example, French economist Thomas Piketty argues in his best seller "Capital in the Twenty-First Century that the GDP growth rates of India and China are exaggerated. Picketty writes as follows:
"Note, too, that the very high official growth figures for developing countries (especially India and China) over the past few decades are based almost exclusively on production statistics. If one tries to measure income growth by using household survey data, it is often quite difficult to identify the reported rates of macroeconomic growth: Indian and Chinese incomes are certainly increasing rapidly, but not as rapidly as one would infer from official growth statistics. This paradox-sometimes referred to as the "black hole" of growth-is obviously problematic. It may be due to the overestimation of the growth of output (there are many bureaucratic incentives for doing so), or perhaps the underestimation of income growth (households have their own flaws)), or most likely both. In particular, the missing income may be explained by the possibility that a disproportionate share of the growth in output has gone to the most highly remunerated individuals, whose incomes are not always captured in the tax data." "In the case of India, it is possible to estimate (using tax return data) that the increase in the upper centile's share of national income explains between one-quarter and one-third of the "black hole" of growth between 1990 and 2000. "
Related Links:
Haq's Musings
South Asia Investor Review
Builder.AI: Yet Another Global Indian Scam?
Is India Fudging GDP to Look Better Than China?
India's IT Exports Highly Exaggerated
Has the Modi Government's Politics Hurt India's International Image?
Pakistan's Official GDP Figures Ignore Fast Growing Sectors
India's "Firehose of Falsehoods"
State Bank Says Pakistan's Official GDP Under-estimated
Pakistan's Growing Middle Class
Pakistan's GDP Grossly Under-estimated; Shares Highly Undervalued
Fast Moving Consumer Goods Sector in Pakistan
Retail Investor Growth Drives Pakistan's Bull Market
Riaz Haq
Pronab Sen, the first chief statistician of India, in a telephonic conversation with Asit Ranjan Mishra, explains his key concern about the latest gross domestic product (GDP) data and the criticism he doesn’t subscribe to. Edited excerpts:
https://www.business-standard.com/economy/news/methodology-of-new-g...
How do you see the 7.8 per cent GDP growth in the first quarter (April-June/Q1) of 2026-27? Does it pass the smell test?
It’s difficult to say whether it passes the smell test because what we have seen is large downward revisions in the recent past. Remember, the first estimate we get for quarterly GDP is based on very, very weak data. So, one can only go by recent history, and recent history has seen fairly substantial downward revisions. So, I am a little shaky about it because I have questions about the data. My personal hypothesis is that this 10 per cent nominal growth they’ve got is probably right. My question is really about the price deflators, which determine real GDP growth.
The Q1 GDP numbers have also become the most contested in recent times. How do you see the controversy that has erupted surrounding them?
I don’t know what all the criticism is. The only criticism I have read is by (former finance secretary) Subhash Chandra Garg.
So, what do you think about his criticism?
I don’t quite agree. The convention has always been to compare the latest estimate with the latest revised estimate.
Garg is also questioning the sharp downward revision of Q1 of 2025-26 nominal GDP under the new base year?
There can be several reasons for it. When you do the base revision, you make corrections for all the overstatements you made previously. Now, usually, these have not been very large. This time, the revision has been large, 7-8 per cent. And the principal reason for it, I think, is overestimation of GDP in the past. So, they’ve just corrected that.
So, what is the real issue with the new GDP series?
I’m questioning the methodology in the new GDP series. Essentially, the changes they have made are all legitimate, desirable, and known earlier as well. The reason we didn’t do it is that we didn't have the data.
There are a couple of things, and they all have to do with prices and price indices. What they’ve done this time around is double deflation, which is a good thing to do. But the point is, it is much more data-demanding. I don’t know whether they have that data. When you are doing single deflation, you need data only on the price of the final goods.
Now, you need prices not only for the final goods, but for all inputs, which is a much larger number of goods. I have not seen any evidence that they have that data.
The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (Mospi) has used the Output Producer Price Index (PPI) in double deflation. But for the input deflator, we do not know whether input PPI has been used because it is at an experimental stage.
I don’t know what they have done. This is my problem because if you are to do the input side, you need input prices. Have they collected them? Have they used them? If so, why have they not been made public? So, my problem is really with the data.
Mospi has said the “sources and methods” will be released within two weeks.
Remember, the new base estimates were released last year. It should have already been released so that we know what was going on.
What are your other concerns?
The second is PPI. We had not been able to calculate the PPI for more than two decades because producers didn’t give us the prices. They said that this is a trade secret. PPI you can only get from the producer. You can’t get it from anybody else, whereas the wholesale price index (WPI) is a market price, which you can go and take quotations. You can’t do that with PPI. The producer has to give it to you.
And quite often, there is no one price because a producer may sell to a large distributor at one price and to a small distributor at a different price. So, he has to give you the average. I don’t know whether they’ve been able to collect this data. And if they have, I don’t know how they’ve done it unless Indian companies have become very cooperative.
Do you think Mospi should have waited for the PPI series to mature before adopting it as a deflator?
The good practice is that when you’re introducing a completely new dataset, you should run the two datasets in parallel. Make the estimates on the basis of the two sets separately and present them to the public. So, you can see what the differences are. But to say, I’m discontinuing this (WPI) and starting this (PPI) abruptly without any further information, what you’re saying, in effect, is, “Trust me”. But trust is only built when you can compare. Now, I can’t compare because I have no overlapping series.
Another contentious issue has been the 9.2 per cent real manufacturing growth, where the deflator has become negative (-1.5 per cent). Is this normal while using double deflation or an aberration?
It can happen with double deflation. With single deflation, it can’t happen.
Mospi has said that there is no reason for the GDP deflator to track the Consumer Price Index (CPI) or WPI because their coverage is different. Do you agree? Questions have been raised about the 2.5 per cent deflator in a quarter when WPI was close to double digits.
It does look suspicious. This is my problem because there are too many things happening. You’re switching from WPI to PPI. You are doing double deflation.
In the UK or Australia, detailed supply-use and national accounts data allow researchers to reconstruct much of the GDP calculation. Why is it not done in India?
Because they don't release the raw data.
So, are you saying that should be released?
Yes. At a certain level of aggregation, of course. You can't release the data at the unit level because there are confidentiality concerns.
But why was it not done even during your time at Mospi?
We have never been in that habit. It’s a matter of habit. But at that time, things were straightforward enough. The CPI data was released in the full breakdown. The entire data set is available for WPI.
Tell me a few things that you would like to see that would give you more confidence in the numbers that have been released.
What I would like to see is basically how they’ve calculated GDP. How they’ve got the data for the PPI. If you’ve got it, please release it for a length of time so that we can check its stability.
Secondly, what on earth have you done with double deflation? Where is your input data? You've given me no indication of that. To do that properly, you would need a massive Supply and Use Table (SUT). Where is that? They discontinued the SUT, in fact. It was being produced and they stopped it.
Not only should they not have stopped, but they should have actually expanded it. And obviously, we should provide more data so that researchers can reconstruct the index. That is better for transparency purposes.
Sep 4
Riaz Haq
Modi’s poverty reduction claims
By Subhash Garg, Ex Finance Secretary of India
World Bank has partnered with Modi Government to create the great poverty reduction illusion in India.
First, look at its claim.
In June 2025, World Bank announced that at $3 per day (2021 PPP), Indian poverty reduced from 27.12% in 2011 to 5.25% in 2022. In October 2026 recently it claimed that poverty had gone further down to 2.7%.
According to these briefs, poverty reduced from 34.44 crore people in 2011 to only about 3.9 crore in 2023. Wow! As good as gone.
In this piece, I explain jugglery of numbers and defective nature of its purchase power parity instrument.
Look at outrageous reengineering of numbers.
Using India’s differently designed 2022/23 Consumer Survey ( which Bank first rejected), World Bank reduced 2011 poverty from 22% to 16% at 2.15 dollar 2017 PPP and increased to 27% in 3.0 dollar 2021 PPP, which should normally be same.
It’s India PPP 2021 was 20.46 rupees in 2017 and has appreciated to 20.09 in 2025 whereas market exchange rate has depreciated sharply.
Poverty has not vanished in India. Its world bank engineered illusion.
———
@subhashgarg1960
World Bank joins Modi Govt to create great India poverty reduction illusion. Using suspect 2022/23 Survey, WB increased India’s poverty at $3 PPP from 22% to 27% in 2011 & reduced to 2.6% in 2023. India 2017 PPP 20.46 is 20.09 in 2025. I unpack the game.
https://www.thequint.com/opinion/indias-poverty-miracle-world-bank-...
https://x.com/subhashgarg1960/status/2120018024069751193?a=KqEHoIys...
———-
"Policy Hard Knock" is a regular economic opinion column written by Subhash Chandra Garg, the former Economic Affairs Secretary and Finance Secretary of India. [1, 2]
Published exclusively on The Quint, the column features sharp, insider critiques of the Indian government's contemporary fiscal strategies, economic policies, and banking regulations. [1, 2]
Recent Column Highlights (Late 2026)
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Trends: In his November 2026 piece, Modi vs UPA: How India Went From Attracting FDI to Losing Out, Garg highlights that India's net FDI has drastically slowed during the current administration's third term, warning that rising outbound investments and lukewarm inflows are draining forex reserves. [1]
Rupee Depreciation & Forex Management: In mid-October 2026 (Forex Reserves Are Bleeding. Can RBI Stop Rupee From Hitting 100 in 2026-27?), he criticized the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) implementation of costly FCNR(B) schemes and hedging restrictions, noting they have unsettled the market and put heavy pressure on the national currency. [1, 2]
Disinvestment Actions: In late October 2026, he used his column to flag severe concerns regarding the IDBI Bank sale, calling the government's downward revision of the bank's reserve price after financial bids opened an unprecedented practice that favors specific buyers. [1]
Contextualizing the Author
Before writing his regular columns, Subhash Chandra Garg authored the definitive book We Also Make Policy. The book offers a fly-on-the-wall account of bureaucratic power struggles, policy friction between the Finance Ministry and the RBI, and the intricate mechanics of high-level decision-making in India. [1, 2]
Nov 10
Riaz Haq
India pulled 500m people out of poverty. Many of them still barely survive | Poverty and Development | Al Jazeera
https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2026/11/15/india-pulled-500m-peo...
India, the world’s most populous country, no longer counts its poor. It has not published an official consumption-based poverty estimate in more than a decade. That leaves the World Bank to provide internationally comparable estimates, using newer consumption surveys and its own poverty thresholds.
A recent World Bank report says India lifted nearly 500 million people out of poverty between 2011 and 2023, with extreme poverty dropping from 27.1 percent to 2.6 percent during the period.
The only comparable poverty-reduction effort on this scale was achieved by China, which lifted more than 800 million people out of extreme poverty over four decades.
Several economists have said India’s achievement is significant, and that the World Bank’s mechanism for calculating these numbers is beyond reproach, even as they have argued that the planet’s most populous nation still has a long way to go before it can claim to have defeated poverty.
Other economists have questioned the World Bank’s sweeping conclusions and India’s unwillingness under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government to carry out its own poverty estimates.
But masked by that largely academic and political split is the lived reality of millions of Indians who have crossed the supposed poverty threshold yet lead a life marked by persistent deprivation, and a precarity that leaves families one shock away from losing everything that matters to them.
“This poverty line, this bar, is very low. No person can live a dignified life [on this amount],” Hema told Al Jazeera, sitting in a small garden where she moonlights as a caretaker.
“Did they even get out of their AC cars?” she asked, taking a dig at the officials who prepared the report for the World Bank.
‘Money now vanishes’
India, home to 1.4 billion people, is one of the fastest-growing global economies – the fourth-largest by nominal gross domestic product (GDP), despite repeated recent shocks including the COVID-19 pandemic and the ongoing wars in Ukraine and the Middle East.
It is also one of the world’s most unequal countries, with the top 1 percent of its population owning 40 percent of its wealth – a concern highlighted in the World Bank report as well.
Hema was 11 when she was married off to a man who belongs to a family of traditional clay-pot makers in Rajsamand district of Rajasthan state.
When pot sales could no longer meet their financial needs, her husband, Hari, started a street food stall selling pani puri, a popular Indian snack. That did not last long because of the pandemic.
Hema started to look for work.
For the past year, she has been cleaning houses and washing utensils in the neighbourhood for 5,000 rupees ($53) a month, but the deprivation did not end.
“We have to buy every single thing from the market,” she said. The family has no agricultural land.
The World Bank pointed to rising female labour force participation as one of the factors behind India’s improving poverty rates, although women’s access to secure and adequately paid employment remains a challenge.
“Since I started working, our home has seen some comfort, but the money is now vanishing faster, and we are even more in debt,” Hema said, adding that she is unable to figure out the maths behind it.
“The prices have multiplied in recent years, and whatever we earn falls short,” she told Al Jazeera.
The World Bank also noted that the Indian government’s provision of free or subsidised foodgrains to nearly 800 million citizens every month under its national food-security programme has helped tackle extreme poverty.
yesterday